Talk:List of religions - Revision history

Ash at 21:52, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T21:52:53Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:52, 24 February 2005
Line 7:		Line 7:
	I mean, the disclaimer at the top that the categories are only one possible system is all fine and good, but why should '''we''' use these categories in Thelemapedia, when they misclassify '''Thelema'''?--[[User:Paradoxosalpha\|Paradoxosalpha]] 20:45, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)		I mean, the disclaimer at the top that the categories are only one possible system is all fine and good, but why should '''we''' use these categories in Thelemapedia, when they misclassify '''Thelema'''?--[[User:Paradoxosalpha\|Paradoxosalpha]] 20:45, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)

	:Yeah, ~~I had a shorter list, and Simon replaced it with~~ the ~~Wikipedia~~ version. ~~This needs~~ to ~~be seriously shortened~~ and ~~recategorized~~. [[User:Ash\|Fr. Ash]] 20:56, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)		:Yeah, the wikipedia version is long and unwieldy...and certainly mischaracterizes Thelema. I would prefer to pare down and reorg this page substantially. [[User:Ash\|Fr. Ash]] 15:52, 24 Feb 2005 (CST)

Ash at 17:24, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T17:24:02Z

New page

Ash at 06:13, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T06:13:44Z

New page

Hey! The category system in this list is a crock!

Thelema is NOT a "Left-hand Path Religion." Thelema is a '''Both-hand Path Religion.'''

"'If thine hand offend thee, cut it off!' is the scream of a weakling." --Aleister Crowley, ''Magick'' (64)

I mean, the disclaimer at the top that the categories are only one possible system is all fine and good, but why should '''we''' use these categories in Thelemapedia, when they misclassify '''Thelema'''?--[[User:Paradoxosalpha|Paradoxosalpha]] 20:45, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)

:Yeah, I had a shorter list, and Simon replaced it with the Wikipedia version. This needs to be seriously shortened and recategorized. [[User:Ash|Fr. Ash]] 20:56, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)

::: Um, I happened to notice this discussion in the recent changes, and, well, there is a shorter list of religions in the article [[Religions]]. Is that the one you wrote? Was this one ''really'' replaced? I'm just curious because you posted a bit of a rant about the same individual on my user page, and I have some serious questions about whether what you said there is true. And it looks to me from the history of this article, that you, Ash, never worked on it. [[User:Aleph|Aleph]]

::::When Simon was doing his major categorization project, he moved a lot of paged that I had created in the beginning. This would explain why my name isn't on the current history. '''Update:''' Here is the original page that I had created: [[Religions]]. I haven't spoken a single mistruth in this whole sordid affair...although Simon would love for you to think so :) —[[User:Ash|Fr. Ash]]

:::::Ash, I don't want to get too personal here, but I have experience with Wikipedia before coming here. History moves along with a page. Maybe not ''everything'' wrong with Thelemapedia is this guy's fault? Just a thought. '''Update''': but if your page is still there, then he didn't do anything to it, did he? Was your page originally called [[List of religions]] or not? It looks like he simply ''added'' a page without touching yours except to add a link to the [[List of religions]] page. [[User:Aleph|Aleph]]

:::::By changing out all the links to it, it is essentially the same thing as replacing that page. A page with no links to it is kinda useless on a wiki, don't you think? And, again for the record, I thanked him for his categorization efforts while he was doing it, even though he was moving and replacing several pages that I had created. I didn't get my panties in a twist about his doing that, because I thought that his changes were overall improvements for the site. I didn't complain then, and I'm not complaining now...although I do think this page needs some serious editing. —[[User:Ash|Fr. Ash]]

:::::But Ash, did you look at the "What links here" page? The only thing that links to this list is [[Religions]] and [[Talk:List_of_religions]]. See [http://www.thelemapedia.org/index.php?title=Special:Whatlinkshere&target=List_of_religions What Links Here]. Clearly, no links were changed to point at this. I understand that this guy may have done some bad stuff, but it doesn't make you look good when you accuse him here of doing something he clearly didn't do!! Your [[Religions]] page is still where you put it, and ''its'' [http://www.thelemapedia.org/index.php?title=Special:Whatlinkshere&target=Religions What links here] page seems to show that you never linked to it from anywhere. Which is strange b/c I remember it used to be linked from the main page. Ah, here it is in the [http://www.thelemapedia.org/index.php?title=Main_Page&oldid=859 page history]. It used to be linked from the "More Religions..." link. Did he change your menu? Or did you shorten it? Inquiring minds want to know who unlinked your page...

:::::I have some other concerns, but I will put them on your user talk page. [[User:Aleph|Aleph]]

:::::Ash, I took a look at the history of the [[Main Page]]. It was ''you'' who unlinked your [[Religions]] page when you [http://www.thelemapedia.org/index.php?title=Main_Page&diff=2634&oldid=2613 made this edit]. You left out the "Religions" section on the new menu... [[User:Aleph|Aleph]]

::::::: I'm going to be honest...I really don't care about this particular issue. You are an excellent detective, and you've found me out. I wasn't able to remember every historical change to this page that I haven't looked at in months. I claimed that Simon added this page...I was right about that. I was mistaken about the relinking. You got me. Just remember, I didn't bring it up. I made a slight error when I said he "replaced" the page...I'll try to be more exacting next time. —[[User:Ash|Fr. Ash]]

Ash at 03:51, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T03:51:44Z

New page

Ash at 03:34, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T03:34:31Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:34, 24 February 2005
Line 11:		Line 11:
	::: Um, I happened to notice this discussion in the recent changes, and, well, there is a shorter list of religions in the article [[Religions]]. Is that the one you wrote? Was this one ''really'' replaced? I'm just curious because you posted a bit of a rant about the same individual on my user page, and I have some serious questions about whether what you said there is true. And it looks to me from the history of this article, that you, Ash, never worked on it. [[User:Aleph\|Aleph]]		::: Um, I happened to notice this discussion in the recent changes, and, well, there is a shorter list of religions in the article [[Religions]]. Is that the one you wrote? Was this one ''really'' replaced? I'm just curious because you posted a bit of a rant about the same individual on my user page, and I have some serious questions about whether what you said there is true. And it looks to me from the history of this article, that you, Ash, never worked on it. [[User:Aleph\|Aleph]]

	::::When Simon was doing his major categorization project, he moved a lot of paged that I had created in the beginning. This would explain why my name isn't on the current history. —[[User:Ash\|Fr. Ash]]		::::When Simon was doing his major categorization project, he moved a lot of paged that I had created in the beginning. This would explain why my name isn't on the current history. '''Update:''' Here is the original page that I had created: [[Religions]]. I haven't spoken a single mistruth in this whole sordid affair...although Simon would love for you to think so :) —[[User:Ash\|Fr. Ash]]

Ash at 03:29, 24 February 2005

2005-02-24T03:29:28Z

New page

Ash at 02:56, 22 February 2005

2005-02-22T02:56:38Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:56, 22 February 2005
Line 6:		Line 6:

	I mean, the disclaimer at the top that the categories are only one possible system is all fine and good, but why should '''we''' use these categories in Thelemapedia, when they misclassify '''Thelema'''?--[[User:Paradoxosalpha\|Paradoxosalpha]] 20:45, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)		I mean, the disclaimer at the top that the categories are only one possible system is all fine and good, but why should '''we''' use these categories in Thelemapedia, when they misclassify '''Thelema'''?--[[User:Paradoxosalpha\|Paradoxosalpha]] 20:45, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)

			:Yeah, I had a shorter list, and Simon replaced it with the Wikipedia version. This needs to be seriously shortened and recategorized. [[User:Ash\|Fr. Ash]] 20:56, 21 Feb 2005 (CST)

Paradoxosalpha: this sucks

2005-02-22T02:45:02Z

this sucks

New page